METHODOLOGY
Methodology and Rating Rubric
Last updated
This page documents where entry data comes from, how it is verified, and the exact meaning of the transparency rating. A directory is only useful if its rubric is explainable — so all of it is written down.
Data sources
- First-party: provider websites, official help centers, and announcement pages.
- Regulatory disclosures: published enforcement actions and typical-case notices (e.g. the People’s Bank of China’s “Typical Cases of Illegal Payment Activities”).
- Second-party: reporting from established financial and industry media.
- Detail pages separate the two; when official and third-party accounts conflict, both are shown as-is without endorsement.
Coverage and delisted platforms
- We cover virtual cards, crypto debit cards, and related wallets marketed to Chinese-speaking users.
- Shut-down platforms are not deleted: entries stay listed, marked inactive, keep their historical notes, and remain indexable so searches like “platform X shut down” find the warning.
- Inactive card BIN pages remain reachable but are marked noindex to avoid thin pages.
Fields and label semantics
- Labels such as KYC requirements and top-up methods are human-maintained directory annotations, not per-provider compliance reviews.
- When a label conflicts with the structured need_kyc field, filtering classifies the entry as unlabeled instead of guessing either way.
- “Unlabeled” does not mean “unsupported”: a missing tag only means no verifiable annotation exists for that dimension.
- The low-fees tag is a historical qualitative annotation — not a verified cheapest-rate claim, and not a price ranking.
The transparency rating
Some entries carry a transparency rating of High / Medium / Low. It measures the quality of a platform’s public information disclosure, on the following rubric:
- High: all of the following hold — the operating entity is identifiable (registration or licence retrievable in public registries), fees and limits are fully published, onboarding and KYC flows have official documentation, and announcement channels are traceable.
- Medium: partially met — e.g. entity information only partially verifiable, an incomplete fee schedule, or an unresolved conflict between official and third-party accounts.
- Low: the entity cannot be located, terms and fees are unpublished, key claims trace only to unverifiable third-party reposts, or the platform has been named by a regulator.
The rating evaluates disclosure quality only — not safety, solvency, or compliance certification. “Low” does not mean a platform is doomed, and “High” is no guarantee of any kind. Ratings are re-reviewed as disclosure changes, stamped with the entry’s update date, and history is never silently rewritten.
Known limitations
- Verification lags reality in a fast-moving industry — the date stamps on each entry are the freshness signal.
- Label coverage is incomplete: an entry with need_kyc=0 but no “No KYC” tag is classified as unlabeled, never forced into either bucket.
- Fees and terms change without notice; every snapshot on this site defers to the provider’s live official terms.